Manager vs Self-booking: How automated policy impacts cost and compliance

Krizia Mojado
Krizia Mojado
Share post on
self-booked business travel

Last Updated on: March 20, 2025 at 3:44 pm

Businesses can unlock efficiency—or quietly drain budgets—depending on how they enforce travel policies. Even with a travel management platform in place, the balance between self-booking and manager-booking travel plays a crucial role in cost control and policy compliance.

Automated policy enforcement ensures that travellers make cost-effective decisions without unnecessary roadblocks. The right policies serve as invisible guides, helping businesses maintain control while allowing employees the flexibility to book efficiently.

Despite automation, gaps in policy enforcement can lead to inefficiencies and missed savings. By examining data from companies with different booking styles, this article highlights where businesses can refine policies to maximize cost savings and compliance.

This article explores how automated policy enforcement helps businesses cut costs and improve compliance. By analyzing data from two companies with distinct self-booked and manager-booked travel styles, we’ll highlight where businesses can refine policies to maximize efficiency while balancing flexibility and control.

Understanding the Data

We analyzed two of our top clients, whom we believe are the most suitable examples, to understand how self-booked versus manager-booked travel impacts cost and compliance. Their distinct travel management styles provide valuable insights into the effectiveness of automated policy enforcement.

36

Self-Booked business travel

For many companies, self-booking is the go-to approach. It gives travellers the freedom to choose their own flights while keeping things in check with an approval process. Travellers onboarded on the platform select their flights, and bookings move forward once approved by a manager. This usually works best when employees understand company policies and know how to make cost-conscious choices.

Manager-booked business travel

In some cases, managers handle travel bookings, especially for travellers unfamiliar with the platform, last-minute trips, or group travel. Since managers typically enforce policies, this approach guarantees compliance and budget control. But it can also mean an extra workload for the managers and less flexibility for travelers.

When manager-booked and self-booked business travel works best

To preface this, there’s no definitive rule on which approach is better. The key is understanding when to use each method based on the specific corporate travel scenario and company priorities. This ensures you maximize the efficiency of your travel management platform.

38

The challenge: Striking a balance

Self-booked flights tend to be 20% more expensive than manager-booked ones. However, relying solely on manager bookings is neither sustainable nor an optimal use of a travel platform.

Finding the right balance between policies and traveller education leads to better platform use.

  • Company A: Self-booked flights cost 21% more than manager-booked ones ($327 vs. $271) but have a low rejection rate (7%).
  • Company B: Self-booked flights are only 5% more expensive than manager-booked ones ($499 vs. $477). Their approval process is stricter, with 10% of requests rejected and more approvers involved.

Company B’s tighter controls help keep costs closer, while Company A’s looser approach results in higher spending but fewer rejected bookings.

37

Key areas for optimization

1. Cost Control

Company A’s self-booked flights were 20% more expensive on average. Nearly half of them exceeded the median fare. Why? No budget thresholds were enforced, allowing travelers to select more expensive options that often required manual approval, leading to rejected bookings and delays.

Company B, which had structured approval processes and budget controls in place, saw only a 5% difference between self- and manager-booked flights.

2. Compliance Impact

Decentralized booking leads to more policy exceptions and higher costs due to lack of automation.

  • Company A: Self-booked flights were 21% more expensive and booked closer to departure, adding up to 23% in extra costs.
  • Company B: Tighter approval processes meant fewer last-minute bookings and just a 5% cost difference between self- and manager-booked flights.

3. Operational Delays

At TruTrip, 90% of bookings are approved without much inspection, yet some still require manual approvals for every booking—causing further delays.

  • What’s causing these rejections?
    • Travelers selecting suboptimal routes that don’t align with company travel plans.
    • Managers identifying cheaper alternatives and overriding traveler selections.
    • Missing travel notes leading to unnecessary rejections.
39

A 2-day booking delay can increase flight costs by 23%. Without automated approval workflows, unnecessary manual interventions can inflate costs and slow down the booking process.

The Solution: Smarter, not stricter policies

Automation should reduce roadblocks, not increase restrictions. The right approach optimizes both self- and manager-booked travel by introducing intelligent controls that maintain flexibility while ensuring efficiency and compliance.

1. Data-Driven Travel Policies

A one-size-fits-all policy rarely works in corporate travel. By leveraging real-time analytics, businesses can refine their policies based on traveler behavior, spending trends, and booking patterns. Data insights can highlight:

  • The average cost difference between self and manager-booked flights.
  • How lead times impact price fluctuations.
  • Trends in policy exceptions and approvals.

By continuously analyzing travel data, companies can fine-tune policies to ensure they align with cost-saving goals and compliance requirements.

2. Enforcing Lead Times

Last-minute bookings tend to drive up costs. Implementing lead time requirements can significantly impact overall savings. Companies that enforce booking windows see reduced airfare costs and fewer booking rejections. This approach doesn’t restrict travelers but encourages proactive planning:

  • Set a minimum booking lead time (e.g., 7 days for domestic flights, 14 days for international travel) to curb unnecessary price hikes.
  • Introduce tiered approvals, where early bookings receive instant approval while last-minute requests require additional justification.
  • Educate travelers on how lead times correlate with price fluctuations to encourage compliance.

3. Business Traveler Education

Many travel inefficiencies stem from a lack of awareness rather than deliberate non-compliance. Training travellers to book smarter can bridge gaps in cost savings and policy adherence. Effective strategies include:

  • Conducting onboarding sessions that go beyond platform navigation to explain policy rationale.
  • Educating travellers on the importance of selecting cost-efficient options that align with company goals.

Empowered travellers make better decisions, reducing the need for excessive approvals and policy enforcement.

4. Automated Approvals

Manual approval processes slow down bookings and increase operational costs. By integrating automated workflows, businesses can streamline approvals without compromising control. Key strategies include:

  • Setting budget caps within the platform to auto-approve compliant bookings.
  • Enforcing geo-restrictions that align with company travel policies to minimize unnecessary approvals.

Automation doesn’t mean losing oversight—it ensures that policy enforcement is efficient, responsive, and adaptable to real-world scenarios.

Final Take: Make It Work for Everyone

  • Empower travellers with real-time price visibility and policy guidance.
  • Reduce manual approvals by automating compliance and budget enforcement.
  • Encourage early, cost-efficient bookings without adding friction.
  • Use real-time analytics to track spending patterns and continuously improve policies.

Instead of reacting to high travel costs, proactive automation allows companies to steer spending strategically—without micromanaging travellers. The result? Lower costs, better compliance, and a frictionless travel experience.

Optimize your travel policies with data-driven insights

Whether self-booked or manager-booked, your travel management approach can quietly impact costs, compliance, and efficiency. TruTrip’s data-driven travel management gives you the insights needed to spot inefficiencies, refine approval processes, and enforce policies without adding friction.

See where your current processes can be optimized. Book a demo today and take the guesswork out of business travel.